3 min read
Updated
Hyperactive Hive Mind Concept By Cal Newport
The Hyperactive Hive Mind, from Cal Newport's A World Without Email: work run on constant, unscheduled messages. What it is, how to spot it, what to try first.
The Hyperactive Hive Mind is a way of working where everything runs through an ongoing stream of unscheduled messages: email, Slack, Teams, texts. Cal Newport describes it in his book A World Without Email. If your team answers questions, makes decisions and hands off work in a chat thread that never stops, you are in one.
This is an unofficial page about the concept. I have not spoken to Newport (he is an on-purpose-hard-to-contact-person in real life). To read the book, click here.
How does Cal Newport define the Hyperactive Hive Mind?
A workflow centered around ongoing conversation fueled by unstructured and unscheduled messages delivered through digital communication tools like email and instant messenger services.
That’s Newport’s own definition, and if it sounds familiar, that’s the point. Nobody chose this way of working. It grew one message at a time because each message was cheap to send.
Why is it a problem for a Scrum Team?
Because the cost lands on the people doing the work. Every unscheduled message is a small interruption, and a day full of them leaves no long stretch for the work that needs one. A Scrum Team is trying to deliver a Done Increment each Sprint, and that takes uninterrupted focus.
It also hides decisions. When an answer lives in message 47 of a thread, the work is not transparent, and transparency is the first pillar the Scrum Guide asks of a team. Scrum already gives you scheduled places for most of these conversations, such as the Daily Scrum and the Sprint Review. A team that works well uses them instead of the stream.
How can you tell whether your team is a Hyperactive Hive Mind?
Ask these three questions this week:
- Do people feel they must reply within minutes? If a slow answer needs an apology, the stream is the real boss.
- Can you find last month’s decision without asking someone? If the answer is “scroll back and hope,” decisions are trapped in threads.
- When did each person last get two uninterrupted hours? If nobody can remember, the work that needs thinking is the work that is not getting done.
Two or more “yes” answers and the pattern is probably costing you more than you think.
What can you try first?
You do not need new tools. Pick one:
- Agree on response times. Tell the team what is urgent (call or text) and what can wait a day (everything else).
- Batch your checking. Look at email and chat at set times, not constantly.
- Move decisions out of threads. Write the decision where the team can find it, and use the Daily Scrum and Sprint Review for the conversations that need people in the same room.
- Turn off notifications for a few hours and see what actually breaks.
I do this myself. My notifications are off, and Slack and email live on my laptop, not my phone. I wrote up the details in Communication Preferences Matter When Implementing Scrum.
Where can you learn more about the concept?
These are additional resources I’ve found:
- BBC Worklife Article: How to Escape the “Hyperactive Hive Mind” of Modern Work
- New York Times: Transcript: Ezra Klein Interviews Cal Newport
- Cal Newport: On Productivity and Remote Work
FREE BONUS: Get ONE actionable item per week through my Focus. #deliver LinkedIn newsletter, or read all of my weekly tips for doing less in order to become more productive. Two themes fit this page best: Protect your focus and Stop the busywork.
What if the stream is your team’s problem?
Fixing this is a team habit, not a personal one, and it is hard to change from the inside. That is the work I do through consulting and mentoring: helping a Scrum Team and its leaders find where the interruptions come from and replace them with something that works. If you want help, email me your situation or read about my advisory work. I’ll tell you honestly if I’m the right person. If your team would rather learn the basics first, see Scrum training.
Weekly, free, no fluff
Get one actionable Scrum idea a week.
Saturday morning emails on Implementing Scrum in the real world — the same cartoons and straight talk that built this site.
Subscribe — It's FreeStuck on something specific? Email me your situation.
